🎯 The Breach: How Crooks Got In

On July 13, 2024, 20‑year‑old Thomas Matthew Crooks ascended to the rooftop of a warehouse roughly 135 meters from the rally stage at Butler, PA, and fired eight rounds from an AR‑15‑style rifle. He wounded Trump in the ear, killed attendee Corey Comperatore, and injured others before being shot by Secret Service snipers KUTV+2KECI+2KFOX+2New York Post+15AP News+15Wikipedia+15.

Crooks executed thorough pre‑attack reconnaissance: practising at ranges, purchasing ammunition and a ladder, and even flying a drone over the site Wikipedia. Local police and SWAT units spotted and reported his suspicious behavior, including carrying a rangefinder and lurking near magnetometer checkpoints Wikipedia. Yet, despite alerts, coordination breakdowns left him unchallenged—and unbody‑searched—outside the perimeter.

🧩 A Cascade of Security Failures

A Senate Homeland Security & Governmental Affairs Committee report, released exactly one year later, details a “cascade of preventable failures.” These included:

Even though counter‑sniper teams and local law enforcement were aware of Crooks, none were posted on the relevant rooftop. Terrain blind spots—such as roof slopes and tree cover—helped Crooks remain unseen Wikipedia+1Wikipedia+1. Moreover, the DHS’s independent panel earlier described the Secret Service as “bureaucratic and complacent,” urging immediate reform Reuters.

🕵️ Aftermath: Accountability & Reform

In response:

  • Six agents were suspended (10–42 days)
  • Secret Service Director Kimberly Cheatle resigned, replaced by Sean Curran Reuters+1The Guardian+1Reuters+11The Daily Beast+11Reuters+11
  • The House task force produced a 180‑page report with 36 key recommendations—spanning training, perimeter control, intelligence sharing, and staffing reforms
  • The Secret Service claims to have implemented 21 of 46 Congressional recommendations—and initiated new aerial detection, mobile command posts, and integrated communications AP News+1New York Post+1.

Yet, critics argue the disciplinary actions fell short and no agents were dismissed AP News+1The Daily Beast+1. Questions linger over motive transparency—Crooks’ motivations remain unclear nearly a year later Wikipedia+4The Guardian+4Le Monde.fr+4.

đź“… What Changed in 12 Months

Under Curran, the Secret Service has upgraded protocols—especially for outdoor rallies and golf outings—and improved interagency collaboration CBS News+4AP News+4KECI+4. Capitol Hill has backed further reforms, including reviewing whether Secret Service duties are stretched too thin across protection and financial policing The Guardian+6CBS News+6Reuters+6.

Despite progress, observers warn that unless structural, procedural, and cultural changes occur—covering everything from rooftop clearances to unified command—the agency remains vulnerable. “Another Butler can and will happen again,” warned independent review panels New York Post.

🔍 Summary

In sum, Crooks penetrated rally security by exploiting a clear rooftop vantage point, lingering in plain sight, and capitalizing on systemic communication and coordination failures. The attack prompted sweeping yet incomplete reforms across the Secret Service and Congress. A year later, while tangible improvements have been made, crucial questions—especially about motives, transparency, and enforcement—remain.

Let me know if you’d like a deeper dive into the technical lessons or legal aftermath.

Key news on Trump’s assassination attempt review